Sunday, November 15, 2026
Settling Accounts
Wednesday, November 11, 2026
Transforming Our Political Order
The recent overwhelming Democratic conquest of the midterm political map has been repeatedly compared to the 1974 post-Watergate Democratic midterm landslide. That is an accurate analogy in terms of the size and scope of the Democrats' electoral sweep. It should not, however, serve as a particularly attractive analogy for Democrats, at least not in terms of any hopes they might have for a transformative political realignment. Remember what happened after 1974! Yes, the Democrats followed up their 1974 midterm win with a presidential win in 1976. But Jimmy Carter's monumentally failed presidency proved to be the end of Democratic hegemony, the definitive end of the old New Deal political order. In political science terminology, Jimmy Carter was a "disjunctive"* president. He represented the end of the previously prevailing liberal, New Deal political order, which dated back to Franklin D. Roosevelt, but which had been experiencing a catastrophic crack-up in the 1960s and 1970s. In retrospect, the 1974 Democratic landslide, followed by Jimmy Carter's relatively narrow 1976 win, was a short-term fluke, a popular reaction against the Nixon Watergate scandals, rather than a foreshadowing of a longer-term political trend. That longer-term political trend was represented by Ronald Reagan, a "reconstructive"* president whose election in 1980 signaled the transformation of the American political order from FDR's New Deal liberalism to anti-New-Deal neo-liberalism.
The three pre-Reagan presidents who, I think, were most politically transformative and "reconstructive" were obviously Andrew Jackson, Abraham Lincoln, and FDR. Those three turned a new political page after the failed disjunctive presidencies of their predecessors, John Quincy Adams, James Buchanan, and Herbert Hoover, whose failures personified the crack-up of, first, the Revolutionary-era patrician political order, then the populist Democratic coalition of the Jacksonian era, and then the post-Civil War Republican coalition. Jackson, Lincoln, and FDR were also transformative in a "small-d" democratic direction, politically affirming and at least initially increasing equality. While also transformative and "reconstructive," Reagan famously differed from those coalition-creating predecessors. Instead of pushing politics and American society in a somewhat more democratic and egalitarian direction, Reagan's transformative realignment pushed politics and American society in a less democratic, more oligarchic direction. A direct political through line runs from the catastrophic 1980 election to today's polarized, angry, oligarchic politics and society. Transformative presidents and political realignments can go in either direction.
There can be little doubt that the 2026 midterm results reflect an anti-oligarchic political move in a potentially more egalitarian democratic direction. Is this the end of the post-Reagan neo-liberal realignment? Two years ago, it was perhaps plausible to suggest that Donald Trump might be another transformative president, promising some sort of populist, post-liberal, reconstructive realignment in the aftermath of the failed, disjunctive Biden presidency. Undoubtedly, Trump has broken the presidential mold, and the old order will not likely be restored in any recognizable way. Trump himself, however, has apparently acquired his own disjunctive end-of-era appearance.
Of course, contemporary politics has scrambled previous political models in ways which may make those older categories untransferable. Even the conventional shorthand characterization of two-term presidents as successful (with the occasional exception like U.S. Grant) and one-term president as failures, falls apart when we have a president like Trump who (like Grover Cleveland) can count as both.
* The terms "disjunctive" and "reconstructive," as descriptions of presidents whose failure marks the end of previously prevalent but now cracking up political order and presidents who replace the outdated order with a new one, are derived from Stephen Skowronek, The Politics Presidents Make: Leadership from John Adams to George Bush (Harvard U. Pr., 1993, 1997).
Monday, November 9, 2026
Mother and Head of All Churches
Recently, when we celebrated the feast days of our cathedral church, I said that, when we celebrate the dedication of a church, we celebrate three things. We celebrate a place, a very special and sacred place set apart unlike any other, which is what it means to consecrate a building. We celebrate a people, the people the place represents and who assemble there. And we celebrate a relationship, the relationship that binds the people together with one another and with others.
So, first, the place. Today's feast celebrates the Dedication of the Lateran Basilica on this date in the year 324. The Lateran Basilica gets its name from the family whose palace originally occupied the site. It was there, early in the 4th century, that the recently converted the Emperor Constantine built a church, a church that was to be the cathedral of Rome, i.e., the seat of the Pope as the Bishop of Rome. Note that he built it not in the center of Rome which was still then a very pagan city, but at the city’s edge. The church still stands just inside the city's Aurelian wall. Originally it was dedicated to Christ our Savior; but later Saint John the Baptist was added to the basilica's title. Hence its popular common name, the Basilica of Saint John Lateran.
The neighboring Lateran Palace became the papal residence, and the whole complex functioned as the center of Christian life in the city - until the Popes moved to Avignon, France, in the 14th century. When the popes finally moved back to Rome in 1377, the Vatican replaced the Lateran as the Pope’s principal residence. Even then, up until the unification of the Kingdom of Italy in 1870 put an end to papal rule in Rome, it remained customary for the Pope to come to the Lateran to impart the Papal Blessing, Urbi et Orbi (To the City and to the World) on certain special days during the year. Since the reconciliation between the Holy See and Italy in 1929, which was formally signed at the Lateran Palace, newly elected Popes have resumed the custom of traveling to the Lateran to ceremonially take possession of their diocese. More recently, Pope Leo has resumed the ancient custom, interrupted by his predecessor, of celebrating the Holy Thursday Mass of the Lord's Supper there.
So that’s the place, a very special place. But, when we celebrate the dedication of a church, we also celebrate the people the place represents, for, as St. Paul reminded the Corinthians, We are God’s building [1 Corinthians 3:9c]. That is why the anniversary of a church’s dedication is celebrated liturgically as a feast for all those whose church it is. As the Pope's principal church, the cathedral church of Rome. Saint John Lateran is, in a sense, everyone’s church. It is, therefore, "the Mother and head of All Churches in the City and the World" (Omnium ecclesiarum Urbis et Orbis mater et caput). Hence, its anniversary is celebrated universally throughout the entire Church.
But, when we celebrate the dedication of a church, and especially when we celebrate the dedication of a cathedral church, we also celebrate the relationship that binds its people together with one another and with others. As the site of the bishop’s cathedra, the chair from which the bishop exercises his teaching office and pastoral power within the local church, a cathedral is a sign of the unity of believers in the one faith, which the bishop proclaims and represents, which is why having a proper cathedral is so important in the life of a local church. As the Pope’s cathedral, the Lateran Basilica is a sign of our unity as believers in the one faith in which, as the successor of Saint Peter, the Pope unites the entire Church across space and time - all around the world and across the centuries.
Friday, November 6, 2026
Looking Ahead Post-Midterms
Wednesday, November 4, 2026
After the Midterms
Monday, November 2, 2026
God's Silence at Halloween
Saturday, our regular "community night" coincided with Halloween, in honor of which several of us watched Ingmar Bergman's classic 1957 film, The Seventh Seal. I first saw The Seventh Seal (along with some of Bergman's other early religiously themed movies) back in my undergraduate college days, when I was living in Chelsea (then a relatively inexpensive, diverse, multi-class New York City neighborhood, unlike what it has since become. In that sense, today's Chelsea neighborhood is a metaphor for our country in this Reagan-Trump era). Bergman was very fashionable then, and the artsy Elgin theater on the corner of 8th Avenue and 19th Street showed his films somewhat regularly. It was part of the wider cultural horizon I was discovering and exploring in those days, while at the same time it connected (however ambivalently) with the long-term religious concerns that perpetually permeated my personal and intellectual investigations then and now.
The Seventh Seal is certainly not a typical contemporary Halloween movie. It is not a horror film, although it may seem somewhat scary in parts and in its style of presentation. It is certainly frightening in its ultimate implication - the fear that there is only "emptiness under the moon." Ingmar Bergman (1918-2007), the son of a Lutheran minister who also served as chaplain to the King of Sweden, directed multiple movies, many of which were religiously themed or displayed intense religious resonances. The Seventh Seal is set in late medieval Sweden during the traumatic period of the Bubonic Plague ("the Black Death"). It stars Max von Sydow as Antonius Block, a Swedish knight returning (with his squire, Jöns) from the Crusades. While searching for meaning in a seemingly doomed world, Block meets and eventually plays chess with Death (played by Bengt Ekerot), presumably in an attempt to delay his own death. The film's title is based on the biblical Book of Revelation's "seventh seal," referenced both in the opening narration and again near the conclusion of the film. When the Lamb broke open the seventh seal, there was silence in heaven for about half an hour (Revelation 8:1). The silence that follows the opening of the seal in the biblical narrative presumably reflects one of the film's central themes, God's "silence," (although the divine "silence" experienced in the film is potentially permanent and signifies a meaninglessness quite alien to the biblical silence).
A 1969 book by Canadian theologian Arthur Gibson, studying seven of Bergman's religiously themed films, was titled The Silence of God: Creative Response to the Films of Ingmar Bergman (Harper and Row). It is interesting to reread Gibson's take on The Seventh Seal, some 50+ years later and try to compare how I react to it now near the end of life versus when I read him in my youth. The same might be said for the movie itself, watching the film now, a half-century later, with all that has happened since then both in our world and in my own life after decades of religious community life and ministry. The "Black Plague" so prominent in the unfolding of the film obviously also resonates very differently now after our very recent plague-like experience of covid. That Plague is central to the way the film functions, although it is actually a historical anachronism. Antonius Block has just returned from the crusades, which would put him at the latest at the end of the 13th century (c.1291), while the Plague only reached Europe in 1347. The juxtaposition, however, has symbolic significance. The Crusades were an optimistic expression of European outreach attempting to restore what had been lost to the Islamic conquerers of the Christian Byzantine Empire's territories. Likewise, the post-war decade when The Seventh Seal was produced and the overall pre-covid secular world were expressions of an unparalleled humanistic optimism and confidence in reason, science, technology, and secular society in general. The medieval Plague produced a society seemingly stuck in a moment of despair. Analogously, we need only recall our own collective national nervous breakdown in 2020, that still lingers in our despairing, traumatized politics, completely undoing the optimistic self-confidence of the late 20th century..
Antonius Block's late medieval Sweden was, of course, Catholic. Hence Block's resort to the sacrament of penance (where, unfortunately, his confessor turns out to be his chess-partner Death himself). Bergman, however, was a 20th-century Swedish Protestant in his religious sensibility. So Block becomes a somewhat Luther-like figure, desperately seeking some guarantee of God, searching in his case for an intellectual certainty which will not be provided, a man alone in the universe with no mediating presence able either to reveal God to him or ease his path to God. Regardless of what the film may or may not have originally intended, it can certainly be seen as a depiction of a world without the Incarnation (or more precisely without faith in the Incarnation). Gibson appears to have recognized this. "The response demanded in the Christian dispensation," Gibson rightly recognizes, "is neither the mere intellectual assent to a series of propositions [Gibson's slam against Roman Catholicism] nor yet the blind faith in an unman [his implicit critique of Protestantism], but rather the personal acceptance of a divine person 'made man'."
in the film, the foil for Block's search for certitude is his squire Jöns, who accepts life as it is - as it presents itself - without further expectations. The interaction between the two is both comic and serious. There is also Joff, the performer, and his family, who represent a purer and simpler, if unquestioning life, and with whom Block finally finds an alternative to his isolation. To Joff in his simplicity and humility, are granted visions, including a beautiful vision of the Virgin Mary with the Christ Child and an alarming vision of the knight playing chess with death, which alerts him to the need for him and his family to escape.
The Seventh Seal's ending, however, dramatic, does not offer a neat resolution. In contrast, Bergman's 1960 medieval religious film The Virgin Spring (which Gibson does not include in his interpretation of Bergman's religious film) serves up a terrible tragedy, followed by righteous revenge and repentance. In his revenge and repentance, the prime protagonist (also played by Max von Sydow) likewise does not achieve certitude, confessing that he does not understand God, but he reconciles with God and vows to build a church at the sight of the tragedy, a site suddenly transformed into an apparent miraculous divine response.
Halloween may be a good occasion to see The Seventh Seal, not because of its potential for fright value, but because of what All Hallows' Eve was originally about - the triumph of the grace of Christ as evidenced in the saints - and in contrast to what it has increasingly become - a celebration of a resurgent paganism's challenge to Christianity. In The Seventh Seal, the witch, Tyan, trusts totally in the Devil and in the Devil's power to protect her. If Antonius Block is a metaphor for disillusioned modern rationalism, perhaps Tyan is the true metaphor for modernity's anxious pursuit of demonic power and modernity's restless search for fulfillment in all the wrong places.
Sunday, November 1, 2026
All Saints Day







